Skip to content
StrattonMB
Book a call
All articles
Published on 20 November 20266 min read

Website redesign: when to do it and how to get it right

Signs you need a new website, how to keep your SEO (301 redirects, Search Console), the key steps, mistakes to avoid and a go-live checklist for your redesign.

A redesign makes sense when your website no longer does its job: it is slow, looks wrong on mobile, is hard to update, no longer reflects your business or has stopped bringing in enquiries. The single most important rule is to protect what already works: pages that get visits from Google must keep their URL or be 301-redirected to their new version. The rest can be planned in a few steps, which I go through below along with a go-live checklist.

How do you know your website needs a redesign?

Some signs are clear. If you tick several of them, the question is worth asking.

  • The site is slow, especially on phones.
  • Mobile display is rough: tiny text, cramped buttons, menus that overflow.
  • You can no longer edit it yourself, or every change goes through a provider who has stopped replying.
  • The content no longer matches your business: old services, old prices, dated photos.
  • Enquiries have dropped for no obvious reason.
  • The technology is outdated: plugins no longer maintained, security warnings, ageing hosting.
  • Your brand has changed (new logo, new offer, new audience) and the site hasn't kept up.
  • You want a feature your current tool can't handle: booking, payment, multiple languages, customer area.

To make the diagnosis objective, I always start with an assessment: speed, mobile display, pages that get traffic, searches the site appears for, technical errors. You can request a free audit to get that starting point.

Full redesign or improving the current site?

A redesign isn't always necessary. If the technical base is sound, targeted fixes may be enough: optimising images, rewriting key pages, reworking the menu, improving your Google Business Profile. I cover these levers in my article on mobile site speed.

SituationRather an improvementRather a redesign
Slow siteImages and scripts to slim downTheme or tool too heavy to optimise
Dated contentPages to rewriteWhole structure to rethink
Mobile displayA few adjustmentsSite not responsive at all
New featureCompatible module availableCurrent tool can't support it
SecurityUpdates still possibleVersion or plugins abandoned

How do you keep your SEO during a redesign?

This is what separates a successful redesign from a drop in visibility. Google knows your pages by their URL. If a page changes address without a redirect, Google hits a 404 error and eventually drops the page from its results. Links from other sites to that page are lost too.

1. Inventory your existing pages

Before touching anything, list every URL on the current site: pages, articles, product pages, PDFs. Identify the ones that matter, using:

  • Google Search Console (Performance report: pages that get clicks and impressions);
  • your analytics tool;
  • pages that receive links from other sites.

2. Keep the URLs that work

If a page ranks well, the safest option is to keep exactly the same URL on the new site. You can change its design and improve its copy, but avoid removing what makes it successful (the topic covered, the main keywords, the useful information).

3. 301-redirect the URLs that change

A 301 redirect tells Google and browsers that a page has moved permanently. Prepare a mapping table: old URL, new URL. Each important old page should point to the closest new page by topic, not automatically to the homepage.

4. Use Google Search Console after launch

  • Submit the new sitemap.
  • Watch the page indexing report in the weeks that follow.
  • Fix any 404 errors that appear.
  • If you change domain name, use Search Console's Change of Address tool in addition to the redirects.

A temporary dip in rankings can happen after a redesign while Google recrawls the site. With clean redirects, it usually stays limited.

What are the steps of a redesign?

  1. Assessment: technical audit, content, pages that bring in business, customer feedback.
  2. Goals: what the new site must deliver (more enquiries, online booking, new audience, new language).
  3. Site structure: list of pages, URLs, redirect table.
  4. Content: keep the copy that works, rewrite the rest, new photos.
  5. Mock-ups: approved together on desktop and mobile.
  6. Development on a staging site that Google doesn't index.
  7. Testing: forms, links, redirects, speed.
  8. Launch and close monitoring in Search Console.

If the redesign is also a chance to change format, for example adding a shop, read brochure website or e-commerce before locking the structure.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Changing every URL without redirects. The most common cause of lost traffic after a redesign.
  • Deleting pages that brought in business because they looked secondary.
  • Redirecting every old page to the homepage. Google often treats these redirects as missing pages.
  • Forgetting to unblock the staging site. A noindex tag or a restrictive robots.txt left in production makes the site invisible.
  • Cutting copy too much for a cleaner design: pages lose the information that made them show up in searches.
  • No analytics at launch: without measurement from day one, you can't compare before and after.
  • Overlooking mandatory information: legal notice, privacy policy, cookie consent, according to the rules where you operate.

Go-live checklist

To check on launch day and in the days that follow:

  • Every 301 redirect in the table is live and tested one by one
  • No important page returns a 404 error
  • The site is no longer blocked (no noindex, correct robots.txt)
  • HTTPS is active, with no mixed content
  • The new sitemap is submitted in Search Console
  • Every page has a unique title and description
  • Forms send messages, and you receive them
  • Call, WhatsApp and booking buttons work on mobile
  • Analytics records visits
  • Your Google Business Profile points to the right website URL
  • Links in your social profiles and email signatures are updated
  • Speed is measured on mobile
  • Legal notice, privacy policy and cookie handling are in place

Frequently asked questions

How long does a redesign take?

It depends on the size of the site and how ready the content is. The redirect table and rewriting often take longer than the development itself.

Will I lose my rankings after a redesign?

Not if working URLs are kept or 301-redirected and useful content is carried over. A temporary fluctuation is still possible while Google recrawls the site.

Can I keep my domain name?

Yes, and it is the simplest option for SEO. Changing domain is possible, but it requires complete redirects and Search Console's Change of Address tool.

Should I redesign everything at once or in stages?

For a small site, a single switchover is simpler. For a large site, you can move section by section, starting with the pages that generate enquiries.

Going further

If your current site feels worn out, start with a free audit: it shows what can be fixed and what justifies a redesign. Ongoing plans for existing websites are on the pricing page.

Let's talk about your project.

A free, no-strings first conversation. Reply within 24 hours.